Musings on a Summer Afternoon - ASL in College
I came to the campus to meet with a couple of my friends to have an ASL meetup mid-week. Sam and Will and I ended up going to Pop-Health on West campus to have coffee/tea and chat for an hour. After which I head to Suzzalo/Alan Libraries to take in the smell of books, the atmosphere if learning, and to skim some books for wisdom.
Today I grabbed the 2009 book “Deaf Subjects - Between Identities and Places” by Brenda Jo Brueggemann. Her book is a series of personally written essays examining various facets of d/Deafness, culture, and related topics.
In chapter 2: American Sign Language in the Academy, she explores the rise in popularity of ASL at the college level, and addresses a question I have long wondered about: where SHOULD ASL “live” within the college structure? At UW, it is in the Linguistics Department, while other languages have their own departments. And I wondered why? I have always come to the conclusion it is a combination of funding and, frankly, not knowing where to put it. So where do other schools place it?
In a 1996 study (the most current at the time of the book’s writing), it was said that 36.8% of schools put it in modern or foreign languages. So what of the remaining 63+% of schools? Some suggest it have its own departments. Some put it in speech pathology, while the rest are split between Deaf Studies, Deaf Education, Interpreting, Linguistics, or Special Education.
the author points out that in many cases, these placements are tied to the concept that one learns ASL to “help” d/Deaf people. Either you are “helping” by teaching at a Deaf school, or you are in some audiology space, or accessibility services. She looks at this and muses:
“Consider for a moment what it means when a language can stand on par with other modern languages in the university structure—even occupy a space all its own—but can also be placed in domains alongside the professional instruction of those who “help” or “service” deaf and hard-of-hearing people. Imagine for a moment if we taught so-called developing-world languages only within departments that might send professionals to relevant developing countries to “help” their people or if religion (through missionary work) or medicine through general health care of even AIDS research or care programs) became the predominant t home for such a language. What a “foreign” idea that would be!”
As she asserts, this is an illustration of the struggle to fit ASL neatly within current academic administrative structures broadly, and language departments more specifically. It is what I often think about here at UW, and ASL’s confused place as the only language learning department that lives under linguistics. German, French, even Norwegian all have their own departments. But for ASL to have the same would require funding said department. And where does that funding come from…? I am very curious who funds the other language departments at UW, and how that is handled administratively. Is this the only real barrier to having an ASL or Deaf Studies major at UW?
And that begs the question. German doesn’t need to have a “German Studies” department under which German language classes are offered. It is an individual language department under which classes on related culture are offered. So I wonder why some schools place it under “Deaf Studies”, with language offered, rather than the inverse model I see here at UW. What is the logic or reason behind this structure? And who decides?
I feel like this phrase has been a driving one since I came back to college, and started my deeper journey into Deaf culture and language: WHO DECIDES?
Who has the influence?
Who has the power?
Who receives the benefit, and what benefits?
Who decides?

Comments
Post a Comment